In this case, PharaCARE is responsible for the death of John's wife and the deaths of 200 other patients because it failed to follow the law or regulation regarding production or marketing of AD23 badges (medications against diabetes). Approval officially authorized by the FDA (Johnson, 2003). The use of AD23 (diabetes drugs) has impacted the health of patients, which is the main cause of death of John's wife and 200 other patients. The company is therefore responsible for this problem. John has the right to file a lawsuit against PharmaCARE in the same manner that Joe Strom filed a lawsuit against J&J Company in the manner described above.