-
Essay / Comparative study of the Bok Iliad and the screen adaptation Troy
The Iliad was adapted into a film in 2004 entitled Troy, in which the story was both radically and subtly altered in its adaptation. A major difference in the film was that there was no intervention or action from the gods, whereas in the book the gods constantly played an active role, ultimately affecting the outcome of the story. Other major changes include Achilles being only a human male, the combination of Briseis and Chriseis into one person, and the portrayal of certain characters' emotions and images throughout the film which subtly change the film with major impacts. One might think that these changes were horrible and in poor taste, but they provide insight into what life would have been like for the given characters without the gods, and the characters in a different light than in Homer's story, whether from a negative or positive point of view. 1.Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why violent video games should not be banned"? Get the original essay In the Iliad, Homer depicts Achilles as a character who is both angry and ruthless, but also emotional and compassionate, with traits both divine and humanist which nourished in his essential being: a demi-god. Due to the lack of gods in the film, Achilles was never shown shouting to his mother in the sea to get his "prize", thus leaving the audience with a lack of empathy and resonance with Achilles. In turn, the removal of this scene and this aspect of the gods showed Achilles in a darker light, as a warrior lacking sympathy or emotions, perhaps even a ruthless killer as Briseis saw him at the beginning of the film . As for the involvement of the gods, subsequent events unfolded with the same results but in a different manner than originally written. In Book XXIII of the Iliad, where Hector and Achilles face off, Achilles becomes a giant pursuing Hector, who felt like Paris was on his side to help him defeat Achilles. The gods played a crucial role in determining the outcome of situations such as Athena returning his arrow to Achilles after he had missed hitting Hector with it. Additionally, without Athena's involvement, Hector knew he was alone all the time, never making a mistake in battle, which would have resulted in giving Achilles the upper hand during battle. On the other hand, this could be considered a good change considering that the help of the gods favoring Achilles was technically a "cheat" when they were helping him in his battles. Also, with the lack of gods in the film, plague and disease were a very real thing and unexplained science instead of Apollo's priests and priestesses praying to Apollo to cause an epidemic. Finally, without the involvement of the gods, there is no comparison to be made between humans and gods to see the remarkable similarities between the two, and for the audience to notice that the gods were just as petty and childish as the humans with whom they played. . This is an extremely important change in that it gave the audience a loss of insight and the characters a loss of guidance and protection. Without validation of the existence or involvement of the gods, all that remained was doubt, little faith, and no fear for the gods. in Troy the Movie. This is shown when Achilles belittles Briseis for his belief that he did not care for or fear them. During Briseis' kidnapping, damage, and attempted sexual assault, she attempts to kill Achilles while he sleeps. In this Hollywood adaptation where a love story must.