blog




  • Essay / Room by Emma Donoghue: Film and Book Comparison

    Room is a novel written by Emma Donoghue. The entire novel is in the perspective of Jack who is cared for by his caring and loving mother. He was born in a room and that's basically all he knows about the environment around him. Her mother was kidnapped by Old Nick when she was nineteen and had been held captive in his shed ever since. She fights to provide the best care possible under the circumstances and restrictions they face. However, sometimes her emotional and noetic state interferes with her responsibilities as a mother, but she remains an amazing mother nonetheless. She is able to come up with a plan that tricks Old Nicks and guarantees them their freedom. The aim of this novel is to entertain the general public. This book is not intended to convince but rather to attract the reader's attention with a plot which, although cruel and inhumane, aims to give voice to those whose story they cannot tell. Room is inspired by the real criminal, Joseph Frizel, who raped his daughter in the basement of his house for twenty-four years. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why violent video games should not be banned"? Get an original essay The differences between the book and the plot of the film are that the book is written from the point of view of five-year-old Jack and of the way he perceives the outside world. , but in the film there is minimal narration from Jack, so we, the readers, really have to understand how Jack would feel at that specific moment. Jack's narration allows us to see the situation from a completely new perspective. The result does not drastically affect the development because the story is still able to flow smoothly, effortlessly, and manages to capture the viewer's attention. Another difference is that in the book we spend a lot more time at the clinic and in the film the pace picks up and we spend it at Grandma's house. The film is constructed in such a way that Dr. Clay and Noreen have become unnecessary to the development of Ma and Jack, but in the book we see the importance they play in how the plot is developed. On the other hand, the similarity between the two is that Joy's father did not want to accept Jack and said that it would have been better if Jack had not been born since he is the product of rape, which creates a constraint in their relationship. the development with Ma and the way the actress portrayed her was quite surreal. I could feel the emotions and rawness in her voice and the desperation she felt to escape the room. On the contrary, I had the impression that the actress did not tolerate the absurdities that the other characters showed her. And her character was quite rushed because even though I see a visual image of her, something could have gone deeper. For example, his psychological well-being could have been addressed, but it was only mentioned a few times. Overall, the actress did an amazing job portraying Ma. Another character is Jack, but the similarities are now uncanny. The actor did an incredible job portraying Jack as he was in the book because he had the innocence that the book exuded and also the physical characteristics that I imagined he would have. One difference however with the character is that I felt like the actor could have had a better development story. They didn't seem to have taken into account the emotional trauma he had suffered, but instead seemed to want to wrap up the story. Room isn't a story about running away and coming home, it's about what they endured and how they seemed to cope with it and move on with their lives without letting their past affect their future. Despite the.